Washing-out image if before tonemapping

[Arakade]

Hi,
I'm trialling Ampliy Motion. When enabled and before Tonemapping (it's 'above' Tonemapping in the effects stack on the camera), it seems to wash out some of the colour. Is this (a) known, (b) expected, (c) avoidable ? Is it an LDR-only image effect?

Specifically here are bad and good:

Image effects

Good:


Bad:


Images

Good:




Thanks, Rupert.
p.s. I'm @Arakade from Twitter. Thanks for your help earlier. Questions relating to local multi-player to follow later.

[Ricardo Teixeira]

Hello Rupert,

Great to hear from you. We usually recommend placing MB at the same level of DoF. We had some artifacts caused by high range values so we're currently clamping those values. This means that, for now, the MB will have to be placed after tone mapping. Soon we will provide proper HDR MB support, you can expect a fix in the near future.

Let us know if you have any additional questions, we would be happy to help.

Thanks!

[Arakade]

ok, thanks Ricardo. So you'd expect tilt-shift (or DoF) to be in LDR (which seems perfectly fine). I'll try that.

I admit I never found anything suggesting recommended order for all these image effects so just moved them around until it looked about right If you know of a resource, I'd welcome

[Arakade]

Just a quick follow-up to say that seems to work fine. Thanks

[Ricardo Teixeira]

Hello,

Happy to know it's working for you.

Unfortunately I don't have additional information regarding Unity component order, it really depends on the effects used.Rule of thumb, first add effects that preserve edge information and then things like AA.

For example: Tonemapping -> MB -> DOF -> AA -> bloom -> grading

Thanks!